Summarizing public comments on federal rules
Deep Seabed Mining: License and Permit Updates
This page summarizes public comments on a proposed federal rule using using AI-assisted analysis and quote extraction. Below is a brief overview of the rule and timeline.
What this rule proposes: The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) is proposing updates to its regulations governing exploration licenses and commercial recovery permits for deep seabed mining under the Deep Seabed Hard Mineral Resources Act. The changes aim to modernize outdated 1980s-era rules by streamlining application procedures and reflecting current technology and international standards. The proposal has drawn both support for improving regulatory clarity and concern over potential environmental impacts to ocean ecosystems.
Official title: Deep Seabed Mining: Exploration License and Commercial Recovery Permit Applications
Agency: National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration
Comment Deadline: September 9, 2025
Published: July 7, 2025
Docket ID: NOAA-NOS-2025-0108
Comment Themes
- biodiversity loss
- environmental impact
- critical minerals
- minimal environmental impact
Public Sentiment
🟢 20% Support
🔴 75.7% Oppose
Based on analysis of approximately 70 public comments.
Sentiment estimates are based on large language model classification (currently GPT-4o), which includes both direct statements and inferred positions. Deduplication helps surface original voices and recurring themes. Our methods are still evolving.
Last updated: 2025-07-19
Requesting an update helps prioritize this rule.Public Comment Summary
This summary reflects the most common points raised in public comments submitted on this rule.
Out of 70 public comments on the proposed deep sea mining regulations, approximately 75.7% expressed opposition, while 20.0% showed support. Opponents raise significant environmental and social concerns, arguing that the regulations inadequately address risks such as biodiversity loss, sediment plume impacts, and threats to marine ecosystems and island communities. They call for stronger environmental assessments, long-term monitoring, and a precautionary approach, urging a halt to mining until robust safeguards are established. Conversely, supporters highlight the potential for environmentally responsible extraction of critical minerals from the seabed, noting advancements in technology that minimize ecological impact. They argue that deep sea mining could reduce reliance on unstable supply chains and decrease the environmental damage of terrestrial mining.
Comment Processing Summary
Out of 70 total comments, we applied multi-level deduplication to reduce repetition and highlight original, personally written submissions. This helps capture a more representative range of public input.
- 69 remained after removing exact duplicates
- 69 after filtering near-duplicates (name swaps, minor changes)
- 58 were considered clearly original (~82.9%)
Generate a Public Comment
✍️ Want to submit your own comment? Use this tool to draft one based on public themes, then copy and paste it into the official docket.
Representative Quotes
Showing 0 out of 57 sampled from original, non-duplicate comments.
Share this rule
Copy and share this link:
← Rules